Understanding Cyber Threats and Threat Actors
Profile a threat actor by motivation, skill and access, and predict which assets each kind of actor is likely to target.
Who would want to break into a pharmacy chain?
On her first day as an intern at Tulsi Health, Riya Menon asks Neha Kulkarni, the IT and security lead, a fair question: who would bother attacking 14 pharmacies in Pune and Nashik? Neha says the question has several answers, and each answer leads to a different defence. A cyber threat is anything that could harm a company's information or computer systems, by stealing data, changing it, or making it unavailable when it is needed. The person or group behind a deliberate threat is called a threat actor. Knowing who the actors are, and what each one wants, tells you where to put your strongest locks first.
Think of the watchman at a housing society gate in Kothrud. He does not treat everyone who walks up the same way. A delivery boy, a stranger trying door handles at night and an angry former tenant who still has a key are all possible trouble, but each needs a different kind of attention. Security teams think about attackers in exactly this way, and the picture below shows the four characters Neha sketches for Riya.
Four kinds of threat actor. Each differs in what they want, how skilled they are and whether they start outside or inside, and those three answers predict what they will go after.
Three questions that describe any attacker
You can describe almost any threat actor by answering three questions. The first is motivation: what do they want? The common answers are money, revenge, attention for a cause, curiosity or bragging rights, and secrets for a government or a rival company. The second is skill: can they write their own tools and plan an attack over weeks, or can they only run something they bought or downloaded? The third is access: are they outside, trying to get in, or already inside with a login and a key card?
Put the three answers together and you have a threat profile, a short description of an attacker that predicts how they will behave. Motivation predicts the target, because people go where their reward is. Skill predicts the method, because a beginner uses well-known tricks against well-known weaknesses, while a skilled group can be patient and quiet. Access predicts the starting point, because an insider does not need to break the front door at all.
Skill and access are two of the three profile questions. The top right corner is the rarest and the most dangerous: someone skilled who is already inside.
Cybercriminals follow the money
A cybercriminal attacks to make money, and money is by far the most common motivation behind attacks, in India and everywhere else. Some criminals work alone, but many belong to organised groups that run like small businesses, with separate people who break in, sell what was stolen and handle the payments. For Tulsi Health the money sits in three places: the 2.4 lakh customer records, which can be sold or used for fraud; the payments and accounts process, which can be tricked into sending money to the wrong account; and the counter billing laptops, which can be locked up and held for ransom.
Criminals behave like pickpockets on a crowded railway platform. A pickpocket does not care whose wallet it is; he looks for the bag that has been left open. In the same way, most criminal attacks are not aimed at Tulsi Health in particular. Automated tools scan thousands of companies for a guessable password or a missing software update, and the attack lands on whoever turns up. Some criminals are highly skilled, but many are opportunists: people with little skill who buy ready-made attack kits online and try them on easy targets. That is why ordinary habits, such as installing updates and using strong logins, stop a large share of attacks.
Insiders already have the keys
An insider threat comes from someone who already has legitimate access: an employee, an intern, a contractor, or a vendor such as Rathi Softech, which can push updates to MedLedger on every counter laptop. The house help who knows where the almirah key is kept does not need to pick any lock. Insiders are hard to spot because, until the moment something goes wrong, what they do looks exactly like normal work.
Insiders come in three kinds. A malicious insider means harm, such as a store employee leaving on bad terms who copies the customer list to sell to a competitor. A negligent insider means no harm but causes it anyway, such as a pharmacist who forwards prescriptions to her personal email to finish work at home, or a manager who writes the billing password on a sticky note. A compromised insider is a real employee whose account an outsider has taken over, so the attacker now looks like a trusted colleague. Careless insiders cause far more incidents than malicious ones, which is why training and sensible permissions matter as much as suspicion.
Hacktivists want to be seen
A hacktivist (hacker plus activist) attacks to make a political or social point. The goal is attention, not money. Typical actions are replacing a website's home page with a message, which is called defacement; flooding a website with so much traffic that real customers cannot reach it; and leaking embarrassing documents. Suppose an online group decides that pharmacy chains overcharge for medicines. Tulsi Health's public website and ordering app become the obvious targets, because a defaced page is something the whole city can see and share.
Hacktivists range from beginners using borrowed tools to skilled, organised groups. Because they choose targets for visibility, a company's public face is at more risk from them than its accounts ledger. Two further kinds of actor exist but rarely trouble a pharmacy chain. Nation-state actors work for governments, are highly skilled and patient, and go after defence, power grids and government data. Competitors occasionally try to steal price lists or customer lists, a crime known as industrial espionage.
Not every threat has a person behind it
Some threats have no actor and no motivation at all. A fire in the Kothrud office, a flooded server room, a power cut during billing hours, a hard disk that fails or a buggy software update can all make data unavailable, which is harm in exactly the same sense as an attack. Security teams list these alongside human threats because many of the same protections cover both. The nightly backup that saves Tulsi Health from a criminal who deletes files also saves it from a failed disk.
Deliberate attackers are only part of the picture. An honest mistake or a failed disk can cause the same harm, and many defences guard against all three.
From profile to target
Once you can profile an actor, you can predict where they will strike first. Ask what reward they want and which asset gives it to them most easily. A criminal who sells personal data heads for the customer database. A fraudster after money heads for whoever approves payments. A hacktivist heads for whatever the public sees. An insider goes for whatever their own login already reaches, which is why giving each person only the access their job needs limits the damage any one insider can do.
| Actor | Motivation | Usual skill | Starts from | Likely first target at Tulsi Health |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Organised criminal group | Money | High | Outside | Customer database, billing laptops (ransom) |
| Opportunist | Easy money, bragging | Low | Outside | Staff email with a weak password |
| Malicious insider | Revenge or gain | Varies | Inside | Customer list, supplier price lists |
| Careless insider | None (a mistake) | Varies | Inside | Whatever they handle daily, such as prescriptions |
| Hacktivist | Attention for a cause | Varies | Outside | Public website and ordering app |
Now practise profiling. Each situation below describes something that has just happened at Tulsi Health. Read the clues about motivation, skill and access, and decide who is most likely behind it; a wrong first answer counts as an incident, because the investigation would start in the wrong place.
The second half of a profile is the prediction: given an actor, which asset do they go for first? Sort each actor below into the Tulsi Health asset they would most likely target, using what they want as your guide.